Outsmarting Insurance Lowball Offers: Your Guide to Fair Personal Injury Settlements 

Reading Time: 7 minutes
Insurance Tactics To Devalue An Injury Lawsuit

If you’re a plaintiff in a personal injury lawsuit, you’re most likely not only dealing with physical pain—but you’re facing financial difficulties and a future filled with doubt. You’re probably counting on a fair settlement to cover your medical bills, lost wages, and other expenses. But what happens when the insurance company offers you a settlement that’s far less than what you deserve? Or no settlement at all? You’re not alone in this struggle.

Insurance companies have their own interests at heart, and those interests often conflict with yours. It’s a harsh reality, but one that you need to be prepared for. Let’s shed light on why insurance companies lowball personal injury lawsuits and how you can protect yourself from being shortchanged. 

Introduction to Personal Injury Lawsuits

Personal injury lawsuits are more than just a series of legal procedures and courtroom drama; they’re about real people—like you—who have suffered due to someone else’s negligence or intentional actions. These cases can range from car accidents and medical malpractice to workplace injuries and slip-and-fall incidents. Each type of case has its own unique legal aspects, but they all share the goal of pursuing justice and fair compensation.

Now, you may ask, “What’s the big deal about understanding the legal aspects?” The answer is simple: Knowing the legal process equips you to make decisions that are in your best interest. In a personal injury lawsuit, you—the plaintiff—seek compensation for different damages. These can include medical bills, which can quickly pile up into a mountain of debt; lost wages, which can put your financial stability on shaky ground; and emotional distress, less quantifiable yet equally impactful.

In a car accident case, for instance, you’d be dealing with the auto insurance of the negligent party. In a medical malpractice suit, it would be the healthcare provider’s malpractice insurance. Each type of insurance has its own set of policies and procedures for handling claims, and understanding these can be your ticket to a fair settlement.

Here’s a fact that underscores the importance of insurance companies in this equation: According to the National Center For State Courts, approximately 95% of personal injury cases are settled before going to trial. Yes, you read that right. The vast majority of these cases are resolved through out-of-court settlements, making insurance companies key players in determining the outcome.

The Dual Role of Insurance Companies: Protectors and Profit-Makers

At first glance, insurance companies appear to be the good guys in the narrative of personal injury lawsuits. After all, they’re the ones who step in to cover medical bills, property damage, and other losses, right? Well, yes and no. While it’s true that insurers provide essential financial coverage, remember that they are not charitable organizations. They are for-profit businesses, and their primary objective is to maximize shareholder value.

To put it in perspective, let’s look at some numbers. According to industry statistics, insurance companies in the United States made over $1.2 trillion in net premiums in 2019 alone. That’s a staggering amount of money, and it’s not all going toward settling claims. A significant portion is earmarked for operational costs, investments, and, yes, profits.

So, where does that leave you? A common misunderstanding is that if an insurance company lowballs your settlement, it’s a reflection of your claim’s validity. That’s not necessarily the case. More often than not, it’s a calculated business decision aimed at preserving the company’s bottom line.

What This Means for You

It means you need to be vigilant. You need to understand that the insurance company’s first offer is often a starting point for negotiations, not the final word. And most importantly, it means you should never handle them alone. Consider hiring a personal injury attorney to make the most out of your settlement.

Strategies Used by Insurance Companies to Lower Settlements

Let’s unpack some of these strategies to give you a clearer understanding of what you might encounter.

Disputing Liability: Shifting the Blame Elsewhere

One common tactic is disputing liability, where the insurance company questions whether the client is actually at fault. Insurers might argue that you, the injured party, contributed to the accident or that a third party is responsible. The goal here is to reduce the amount they have to pay out or, in some cases, avoid payment altogether.

Downplaying Injuries: The Subtle Art of Minimization

Another strategy is downplaying the severity of your injuries. Insurance adjusters may request medical records, consult with healthcare providers, or even hire independent medical examiners to argue that your injuries are less severe than you claim. This tactic serves to lower the value of your settlement, potentially leaving you with insufficient funds to cover your medical expenses.

Delay Tactics: The Waiting Game

Time is often of the essence in personal injury cases, especially when medical bills are mounting and you’re unable to work. Some insurance companies exploit this urgency by employing delay tactics. They might take an excessive amount of time to review your case or respond to your attorney’s communications, hoping that financial pressure will compel you to accept a lower settlement.

The Implications of Accepting a Lowball Offer

When you’re in the midst of a personal injury lawsuit, the temptation to settle quickly can be strong. After all, you’ve got bills to pay and a life to get back to. But if you accept a lowball offer from the insurance company, you may be selling yourself short. 

Firstly, let’s talk about medical expenses. Accepting a low offer might cover your immediate bills, but think long-term. Medical conditions often require ongoing treatment. For instance, a car accident injury might require not just immediate emergency care but also long-term physical therapy. If you settle for less now, you’re essentially paying out of pocket later.

Now, let’s consider lost wages. If you’re unable to work for an extended period, a lowball offer won’t sustain you or your family. You might think you’re losing just a month’s salary, but what about the ripple effects? Your inability to work could affect your career trajectory, promotions, and even your retirement savings.

Moreover, there’s the psychological impact to consider. While it’s hard to put a price on your emotional state, it is a significant and important factor in personal injury matters. A lowball offer won’t compensate for the stress, anxiety, and emotional fatigue that often accompany these incidents.

Lastly, let’s not forget that you might be setting a dangerous precedent, not just for yourself but for others in similar situations. By accepting a low offer, you’re essentially signaling to insurance companies that these tactics work. This could make it harder for others to get fair compensation in the future.

Tips to Avoid Being Lowballed by Insurance Companies

First on the list is consulting a lawyer. Now, you might think, “Do I really need a personal injury lawyer for this?” The answer is a resounding yes. A seasoned personal injury attorney will fight on your behalf and make sure that you’re not taken advantage of. Attorneys also provide a realistic valuation of claims (so you know what you’re entitled to.) Think of it this way: you wouldn’t go into a scary medical procedure without a skilled surgeon, so why enter a legal battle without expert counsel?

Next, let us move on to the topic of documentation. In the digital age, keeping records has never been easier. Yet, many people overlook this critical step. Document every medical visit, every treatment, and every piece of correspondence with the insurance company. These records serve as your proof when negotiating a settlement. For example, if the insurance company argues that your injuries are minor, your medical records can prove otherwise. It’s like having a set of verified receipts that validate your claim.

Now, onto negotiation. The first offer from an insurance company is often a lowball figure, designed to test whether you know the value of your claim. Don’t fall for it. Be prepared to counter-offer. Here’s where your lawyer, through your documentation, can negotiate from a position of strength. 

Here are some additional tips that can fortify your position:

  • Seek Multiple Medical Opinions. Don’t rely just on one diagnosis. Multiple medical opinions will provide a fuller picture of your injuries.
  • Use a Settlement Calculator. There are online tools that can give you a ballpark figure for settlements in cases similar to yours. While not fully accurate, you can get an idea of what your case will settle for.
  • Be Patient. As mentioned, insurance companies often delay settlements to pressure you into settling. Remember, time is on your side. The more thorough your case, the stronger your negotiating position.

Conclusion: Pushing for Fair Representation and Adequate Compensation

As you can see, insurance companies are in the business of making money. Every dollar they pay out in settlements is a dollar less in their coffers. This profit motive often leads them to offer “lowball” offers, hoping the injured party will accept a lesser amount to close the case quickly.

However, it’s absolutely essential that you recognize that the stakes are higher than quick money. You’re not only negotiating for yourself; you’re setting the stage for how insurance companies deal with personal injury claims moving forward. That means that your actions today have a ripple effect on the treatment of future personal injury victims.

The road to a fair settlement is filled with potential pitfalls. Yet, with the right legal representation, case documentation, and a well-thought-out negotiation strategy, you can tip the scales in your favor.

As we look toward the future, the call for reform becomes increasingly urgent. It’s high time we collectively advocate for the fair treatment of personal injury victims. This involves pushing for policy changes that deter insurance companies from taking advantage of claimants. After all, your well-being should never be a line item on an insurance company’s balance sheet. Stand firm, know your rights, and insist on the compensation you rightfully deserve.

Need Lawsuit Funding? A Helping Hand When You Need It Most

You’ve done everything by the book: secured a skilled attorney, meticulously documented your case, and entered negotiations. Yet, the mounting bills are becoming a second source of pain, almost as painful as your physical injuries. It’s a situation no one should have to endure, yet it’s a reality for many personal injury victims. This is where Baker Street Funding’s pre-settlement loans can offer the financial assistance you so desperately need.

Let’s get real—waiting for a fair settlement can be a long, drawn-out process that destroys your finances, but it doesn’t have to be. A pre-settlement loan from Baker Street Funding is more than a quick cash infusion; it’s a financial tool that puts you back in control. This isn’t about charity; it’s about giving you the financial stability to hold out for the settlement you truly deserve.

With quick approval times and no repayment if you lose, you’re free to concentrate on healing from your injuries and fighting for the compensation you deserve. Baker Street Funding provides a safety net for those who need it most—and that’s something you can count on.

So, as you try to get through your personal injury claim, remember that you don’t have to go it alone. Financial support is available, and it’s tailored to meet your financial needs. Apply for a settlement loan today and take comfort in knowing you have a financial ally ready to support you.

At Baker Street Funding, we give you the inside scoop on pre-settlement funding by covering a variety of ... financing and legal topics to help you made the best financial decision for you and for your case. Our experts break down complex ideas in a way that's easy to understand so you can stay informed on current trends as well as tips and fact checked information by the CEO and founder, Daniel Digiaimo. Furthermore, Despite its name, consumer legal funding is not a loan. If you don't win your case, no payment needs to be made back. To avoid confusion and simplify matters on, we'll use the word "loan" throughout this article.

Select a legal funding service to get started. 

Attorney Requests

Lawsuit Loans

Litigation Funding

Personal Injury Loans

Settled Case Loans

Surgery Funding

Or just call us at 888.711.3599 to apply.